Wooden spoon mere symptom of Scottish rugby's troubles

Defeat to Italy at the weekend means Scotland are now on the worst losing streak since 1998 and serious questions are being asked about Andy Robinson's leadership.

But the problems for the Scottish game run a lot deeper than the coach's ability or lack of it.

The SRU has been attempting to change its image from blazer wearing club buffties to a slick professional organisation for a number of years now but what has really changed, not much.

Whereas defeat to England and France earlier in the tournament could be put down to some poor decisions on the park, the reality is that there was an inevitability about defeat in Rome. The sands of world rugby are shifting and if Scotland don't shift with them they will be buried.

The home truth is that until the SRU gets serious about broadening the appeal of the game in this country its future will be one of decline.

According to their own latest statistics there are just over 50,000 registered rugby union players across all ages in Scotland. Roughly the percentage of rugby players in Scotland per head of population is around 1% in Wales and England it is about 5% in New Zealand nearly 7%.

Here lies the crux of the problem. There is simply too few players playing the game to get a squad of a decent enough standard to make any sort of inroads in to the world game. For instance not one single player from a Glasgow state school has ever played for Scotland, ever.

This is not just a Glasgow public relations problem. Yes the round ball rules, but the SRU makes virtully no attempt to broaden the appeal of the game outside its core areas of Edinburgh, the Borders and former pupils of Glasgow's public schools. In reality it still relies almost exclusively on its traditional base geography for players. Improving the offering in these areas will help but it won't dramatically increase the numbers playing the game.

Even the loyal rugby loving middle class has seen the writing on the wall. Last season was the first time since Murrayfield was redeveloped that it failed to sell out any games.

Yes, they can pull off the odd result but that will become more and more infrequent as the balance of power in the game shifts.

Perhaps it's time to give up the pretence of being a leading nation. Now rugby has been nominated an Olympic sport countries like Russia are already investing millions into the game's development.

With Scotland already making heavy weather of getting past so called second tier teams like Romania and Georgia, without similar investment and vision to make the game more appealing to a broader church, there will be a massive change in Scotland's world ranking sooner rather than later. It isn't going to be up the way.

As an aside to this sorry state of affairs isn't the fact that no Scottish referee has officiated over a international match for nearly ten years merely reinforce the view that the development of the game in this country is sadly neglected?

And Andy Robinson can't shoulder the blame for that. 

 

 

 
Comments (3)
3 Tuesday, 29 November 2011 13:58
I would agree Brodie that the need to broaden the appeal of the game is critical to not just the game's growth but its survival
2 Wednesday, 23 November 2011 22:07
I think there is a definite need for promoting rugby in more Scottish Schools, along with a lot of other sports such as cricket and tennis. Having grown up in Australia I was blessed with being subjected to every sport imaginable and forced to play a summer sport and a winter sport after School twice a week with games on the weekend. If you skipped sport at my old school you'd get detention.

There also seems to be some very strange social attitudes towards certain sports in Scotland. For example, a lot of people i've met who like football consider rugby a posh person's sport!?! Many other fellow Scots I've met seem to despise cricket or tennis because they are considered "English". To be quite honest these attitudes make feel sad to be Scottish. The SRU have to make a better effort to promote rugby in more working class communities.
1 Saturday, 22 October 2011 15:15
This decline, or rather treading water, does somewhat mirror that in the Nation's fortunes in it's national sport, footie. Are we reaping the whirlwind of teacher's strikes in the 80's and rise of alternative outlets for sport and leisure, or does the country just not care anymore? You are correct about more outreach being needed, but do you target the kids via school or through the clubs? Whatever, professionalism doesn't appear to have helped the gam e as a whole, and I am not sure if we can blame the SRU alone for that.

Add your comment

Your name:
Your email:
Subject:
Comment:
website by ifoundry